• 5 Posts
  • 540 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 4th, 2023

help-circle


  • Yeah, but if your aim is to write FOSS clones of proprietary software (be it SaaS or otherwise, or even if your aim is to write something bespoke rather than a clone of something that exists), doing it with LLMs is either going to take you longer than writing it yourself or result in laughably glitchy, inferior software.

    Remember the news that went around not too long ago about how a company “used AI to make an Open Source Photoshop”? The part everyone left out is that even the company behind it calls their “Open Source Photoshop clone” “early alpha”. (At the top-right.) It’s barely a tech demo. Not a product. And I doubt it ever will be, despite the hype about it in the news. If it ever does end up rivaling Photoshop, it’ll only be because they gave up on using LLMs (which will be more work in the long run than if they just hadn’t used LLMs in the first place – or just contributed to Gimp) or because Photoshop will enshittify enough that the terrible quality of whatever PhotoCraft eventually becomes will be preferable.

    Same with any other effort to make FOSS clones of existing proprietary software.

    I’m 100% all for making compatible FOSS clones of existing proprietary and SaaS software specifically to break the monopolies held by companies like Adobe and Microsoft and Amazon. I would love to be able to recommend ReactOS to relatives. And I’ve played a “lot” (compared to most people, at least) of FOSS re-implementations and/or clones of originally-proprietary games or game engines (OpenMW, OpenJK, DXX-Rebirth, Lilium Voyager, Luanti). But LLMs aren’t magic and won’t help.




  • I have to ask. What does it mean to have “learned” the languages you listed?

    I’ve been a professional software engineer for 20 years. I’ve been writing in the Go programming language for 14 of those years. And not once have I touched a debugger… until a couple of nights ago. I bring that up to make the point that “learning” something like a programming language is an ongoing process. I sometimes forget things and have to relearn them. And I learn new things I never knew before about Go almost every day. I guarantee I have a ton left to learn. I can name several of them off the top of my head. And that’s even without considering all the new things that will be added to Go in the future. Or to mention all the other languages I regularly write in. OpenSCAD, for instance, is a much simpler language than Go because of its narrow, niche focus. I’ve been writing OpenSCAD code for a good… 8 years or so, and I learn new things about it pretty much every time I use it as well.

    I don’t view things in terms of having “learned” a programming language. I’ve learned everything I needed to learn to accomplish each of the projects I’ve done. I’ve also learned things here and there just by watching a random YouTube video or reading a blog post. And I’ll continue to do just that.

    My recommendation: make something that you want to make. Learn what you need to learn to make it. It’s fair to make it something relatively small; something that’s only a little bit of a stretch. Or something that’s a big stretch is fine as well. Don’t do the project just to learn. Make your project something you genuinely want to see in the world. Learn by doing and do by learning. Think of the two as one and the same activity. Try to figure out the “right” way to do the thing rather than the “easy” way. And find the fun in thinking deeply about a problem and working through building it until you’re happy with the result.








  • Took me a while to even figure out vaguely what you were talking about here. I use DuckDuckGo exclusively for search. (And I use DuckDuckGo for search mostly because they let me turn off LLM BS.) I wasn’t aware they offered a browser. (I assume what you’re talking about is the DuckDuckGo browser/app, right? Not, say, search or LLM services or whatever.)

    When you say “browsing and tracking through my apps”, what do you mean exactly? Did you have the impression that having the DuckDuckGo browser installed on your phone will prevent other apps from tracking you somehow? Or are you saying that by using the webapp of whatever particular service through the DuckDuckGo browser rather than an official app, you avoid tracking built into the app? (If that’s what you’re saying it at least sounds plausible. But if you’re thinking having DuckDuckGo on your phone will prevent, say, Google Play from tracking you (assuming Google Play is installed on your phone), I can’t see how that could be the case. But I also wouldn’t think DuckDuckGo would make the claim that it would. Unless you and DuckDuckGo know something I don’t.) Or when you say “browsing and tracking through my apps” do you really mean web trackers? (Or maybe apps can interact with web stuff through the browser in ways that I’m not thinking of.)

    I guess what I’m asking is what specifically is the privacy claim related to DuckDuckGo that you’re asking the veracity of?

    Whatever the case, it’s entirely possible that the particular claim you’re asking about isn’t true, but that it’s also not a claim that DuckDuckGo makes nor that they’d expect people to think about their products and so isn’t any particular reason for your coworker to dunk on DuckDuckGo.


  • My experience is that the performance of videos depends a lot on how much of the screen the video takes up. More so than on the quality setting (480p, 720p, 1080p). Usually when I want to watch a video, I limit it to about 1/4 of the area of my 1920x1080 screen. But YouTube is pretty watchable. I don’t think even when you select something like 720p@60fps or whatever that it ever actually gets up to 60fps, and sometimes the parts that don’t compress as well drop a few frames (strobing in particular does that), but it’s really not bad if you’re ok with not doing full-screen.

    Also, it depends where the video is hosted. If the JS is really light on the page, it’s way more performant. If the JS is really heavy, I sometimes have to wait tens of seconds for it to render the first frame.

    But also, this Raspberry Pi is mostly my Lemmy box. Not my main box.





  • does it know the contents of the page despite tor?

    The cafe’s network can’t see the content of your network traffic. Just the encrypted version (which to it is indecipherable). They can see roughly how much data you’re uploading and how much data you’re downloading. If they are blocking things and that’s why videos aren’t working, it’s probably just based on how much data you’re downloading through a given connection. My guess is that they drop the connection after a certain number of megabytes or some such. (Do videos start to play and stop shortly after starting? Or do they refuse to start? If they refuse to start, it might be more that Invidious (or maybe Cloud Flare or some such on their end) blocks Tor. If it is on Invidious’ end, it may or may not be intentional that it doesn’t work with Tor.)

    The cafe also can’t tell by inspecting your traffic who the “other end” of the network connection is, just that one end of the connection is your computer.

    But…

    The cafe almost definitely has cameras. If the cameras can see your screen, or if your screen is in view of staff or other patrons at the cafe, then that could be just as bad as inspecting your network traffic would be. It’s unlikely they’d block videos that way, but it’s at least as much of a privacy concern as inspecting your traffic would be.


  • It’s like a koan. I keep expecting “and then he was enlightened” at the end.

    You’ve figured it out. Take as much advantage of your employer as you can. Try not to make life harder on your coworkers. People matter. Heartless corporations don’t. Eek out as much fulfillment as you can within that context. There’s nothing better. At least not within capitalism.