I’m not trying to get anyone in trouble here, but why hasn’t anyone tried to steal youtube’s content and make it available to non-paying users (read: users who refuse to partake in surveillance capitalism).

In the old days we had the piratebay and many others that basically refused to respect “property rights”. YouTube has a massive advantage for coercing people into giving their personal data; you can live your whole life without seeking Facebook’s Meta’s content, but anyone will have to watch a youtube video at some point, and they are very effective at paywalling their content. Front ends still provide your IP address to YouTube which then blocks you if you have any decent proxy/VPN.

In the case of YouTube it is reasonable and acceptable to steal their content and even sell it forward, as the seller is not profiting off the content but off the privacy service it would be providing.

The structural functionalism school of sociology sees crime as necessary for evolution and change in society, but really we can skip the rigorous academic reasoning: this is pretty obvious for most of us who can trace enough of our ancestry to a commercial (and lawful) transaction.

        • kuiskaaja@lemmy.ml
          24·
          2 days ago

          this is what it was a reply to lol.

          i was actually defending someone liking certain types of games

          if youre going to dig for shit in someones comment history, please check the context of the comment before weaponizing it

          ty

            • kuiskaaja@lemmy.ml
              23·
              2 days ago

              i don’t understand what you’re trying to say.

              the guy i replied to was shitting on the OP for liking normie games and i came to the OP’s defense

              edit: oh yeah i see what you mean now. i don’t actually like those games, i felt that it’s fine to play whatever u want.

              playing games in your private time and minding your own business is different to acting cringe on a public forum.

                • kuiskaaja@lemmy.ml
                  22·
                  2 days ago

                  that’s fine if you have a problem with it.

                  i have a problem with people embrassing themselves online.

                  i think we can just move on

                  • Bilb!@lemmy.mlEnglish
                    2·
                    2 days ago

                    I happen to agree with your assessment that talking like a pirate when you’re being circumspect about copyright infringement is cringe. (Moer liek incringement, amirite?) I don’t usually love to make judgements like that, but man, so-called “pirates” need to lighten up. They think they’re warriors on the frontline of an important battle, but they’re just downloading anime or whatever without paying. I do it too, but getting all self righteous about it is EMBARRASSING.