FYI this will be fixed in Lemmy 0.17

I always thought that .ml was used simply because its free. But what do I know…

Looks like you are running the dev branch of lemmybb which requires Lemmy 0.17 (not released yet). For now you need to run lemmybb release 0.1.2.

Thank you i opened an issue.

https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy-ui/issues/897

It helps a lot to realize that we are not obligated to respond to anyones issue. Wee are providing a software for free, and if sonething cant get it working, thats their problem. They can just not use it, or pay someone for help. Just because I wrote some software doesnt mean I owe anyone an explanation how it works.

In this regard I think it will be helpful if we aggressively close any support requests on Github, and tell people to ask on Lemmy/Matrix, where other people can help them.

So you have the same approach of generating a title from the post body. Only you do it on the frontend and not the backend. In Lemmy that might be a bit complicated because the body is already optional, and we would have to somehow encode that either title or body must be set (or both).

Could you show an example screenshot how that looks like? I cant really imagine it working in Lemmy.

Posts without title would completely break post listings in Lemmy.

The Activitypub standard doesnt mandate any specific properties, not the title and not even the content which Mastodon sends. Thats one problem with Activitypub, you can send almost anything you want and its technically valid (even if no other platform can handle it). However the presence or lack of a title isnt really related to groups.

Direct link to the blog post: https://nolanlawson.com/2023/01/09/retiring-pinafore/

Not so good, because this would require a lot of customization options to fetch communities according to different criteria. I think this makes much more sense as an external tool, then it can have a config file or be forked for different behaviour.

Thanks, i updated the link.

Crossposts are only implemented in the frontend (using search afaik). The backend doesnt know anything about this concept and so cant federate it.

It would be pretty easy to write a bot which does this automatically. Problem is that you could easily end up with a lot of spam or other unwanted content.

The cross-posts for a given post are not federated. This means you will only see cross-posts in cases where you or someone else on your instance already follows the communities where it was posted. So they dont help for discovering content on a new instance.

You need to wait for Lemmy 0.17.0 for this to work.

In addition to what @Austin_Skeldon@lemmy.ml says, another problem is that each software prefers to implement things in their own way, and not in the way that would be most compatible with other software. This is partly the fault of Activitypub, because its such a generic protocol that the same information can usually be represented in many different ways.

Another big problem is funding and thus developer time. Only few devs are paid to work on Fediverse software, and its not enough to keep up with all the work. So compromises have to be made, and often a nice user interface or other features are seen as more important than perfect federation.

Doesnt look like this can be selfhosted.

Running checks on multiple services creates multiple points of failure, so if any one goes down, it takes time to investigate and fix that. So I dont see any benefit to this.

On this page you donation options. However renting a fast vps is generally very expensive, so selfhosting is much more cost effective. That needs some time and to setup and manage though. As we already host a number of different servers, it would be helpful if someone else could manage this one.